These are provided by way of example only. Other damage categories
may also fall within the economic loss column. So, without
a fire, earthquake or other catastrophic event causing actual
physical damage, the Court has refused recovery.
However, the laws governing community managers and board's
duties remain the same. The following are just some of the
fiduciary duties you are required by law to meet:
| 1. |
DUTY TO REPAIR AND MAINTAIN COMMON
AREAS (Civil Code §1364) |
| |
Associations are required to repair and
maintain common areas. If an association investigates
other claims and finds defects that have not manifested
in any physical damage, the association is still required
to fix the problems. |
| 1. |
DUTY TO INVESTIGATE POTENTIAL CONSTRUCTION
DEFECTS (Corp. Code §7231(a)) |
| |
Association board members must exercise
sound business judgment, including the duty to undertake
"reasonable inquiries" into matters affecting the health,
safety and financial well-being of the members under Corporations
Code section 7231(a). |
| 1. |
DUTY TO MEET STATUTES OF LIMITATIONS/TIME
LIMITS (C.C.P. §337.5) |
| |
An action that is not initiated within the
designated time limit of ten years from the date of substantial
completion (337.1) or three years from the date of discovery
of the defects (338) will be forever barred. This is the
primary defense a builder has to claims for defects. Failure
to meet these deadlines constitutes a breach of fiduciary
duty and this decision has not changed these time limits. |
| 1. |
DUTY TO DISCLOSE (CIVIL CODE §1368
and §1368.4) |
| |
Full disclosure of common area defects must
still be made to association members, even though the
association may not recover damages for certain defects.
The rules of disclosure have not changed, including disclosure
to prospective purchasers and notice to members prior
to filing civil actions. |
Even though the damages your association recovers may be
less than before, common area construction defects do need
to be addressed and failure to meet these duties above could
expose management to liability.
A determination of what amounts to "actual physical damage"
should be left up to experts. Investigations by experts and
an analysis by construction defect counsel is required to
determine what amounts to a defect. Now, more so than ever,
referring to a construction defect specialist is important
because there are significant legal theories that must be
made and only a litigation specialist will understand these
legal intricacies. Managers should defer to these experts
when the possibility for defects arise.